‘Expedition to Banu Fazarah & Killing of Abu Rafi’
After recitingTashahhud, Ta‘awwuzand Surahal-Fatihah, HisHoliness, HazratMirzaMasroorAhmad(aba) said that he would continue mentioning the expeditions during the life of the Holy Prophet (sa).
His Holiness Hazrat Mirza Masroor Ahmad
Was Umm Qirfah Really Killed By the Muslims?
His Holiness (aba) said that in relation to the Expedition of Banu Fazarah, there is mention of the murder of Umm Qirfah. Upon analysing historical accounts, it becomesevidentthatthisisafalseincident. HisHoliness (aba) quotedHazratMirza BashirAhmad(ra) who writes:
‘In place of the above-mentioned Sariyyah of Hazrat Abu Bakr (ra), Ibni Sa‘d has mentioned a Sariyyah wherein Zaid bin Harithah (ra) was the commander. In otherwords, IbniSa‘d mentionsZaid binHarithah asthe commanderof this Sariyyah insteadof Hazrat Abu Bakr (ra). Moreover, differing in details as well, he writes that this expedition was to discipline the Banu Fazarah, who resided near the Wadi’ul-Qura’ and who had attacked a trade caravan of the Muslims, stealing all of its wealth and goods. The driving force behind this mischievous group was an old lady, named Ummi Qirfah, who was a staunchenemyof Islam. Whenthisladywascaptured, a man namedQais from thepartyof Zaid killed her. Moreover, Ibni Sa‘d describes the story of this murder such as bothof herfeetweretiedtotwodifferentcamelsandthen thesetwocamelsweredriveninopposingdirections, due to which this lady was literally torn in two pieces. After this, her daughter was entrusted to Salmah bin Akwa‘ (ra). It is this story which to some extent, has also been mentioned by Ibni Ishaq with brevity, abridgment and variation.
On the basis of this narration, Sir William Muir, who is accustomed to providing more details than most European historians, very enthusiastically makes this occurrence the highlight of his book as an example of the ‘barbaric spirit’ of the Muslims. As a matter of fact, Sir William wrote that the very reason he included this in his book was because the Muslims committed a cruel deed in this Sariyyah. As such, Mr. Muir wrote:
“Therewereseveralunimportantraidsthisyear hardlyrequiringmention, butImustnotomitonefor thecruel deed that closed it.”
A historian who gives preference to one occurrence overanothermerelyonthebasisthatitfurnishesproof of thebrutalityandruthlessnessof apeopleandmakesitthe highlight of his book, is in actuality not worthy of being referred to as an unbiased researcher. This is because it can never be expected that such an individual would pay attentiontoinvestigatingwhetherthisoccurrenceof brutality and ruthlessness was even true or not, because indoingso, aproof inhisfavourislosttohim. Inanycase, Mr. Muirhaswrittenthisaccount inhisbook withspecial enthusiasm. However, as shall now become evident, this occurrence was completely erroneous and categorically baseless. Furthermore, both in terms of record and rationality, this narration is vindicated as being fabricated.
In terms of rationality, it should be known that to imprison a lady who is not convicted of murder and then to kill her in calmness and then to kill her in the manner which is related in this narration, is something quite untenable. Islam strongly prohibits even killing women in the very field of battle and we have already mentioned theinstructionsof theHolyProphet(sa), whichheissued in the prohibition of killing women in the fundamental discussion on Jihad. As such, it is mentioned in a Hadith that on one occasion, a woman of an enemy tribe was found dead in the field of battle and even though it was notknownwhichcircumstancesandbywhosehandshe had been killed, upon seeing this, the Holy Prophet (sa) wasverydispleased. TheHolyProphet(sa) emphatically stated to his companions that this should never happen again. Similarly, it has also been mentionedthat whenever theHolyProphet(sa) wouldsendoff anarmy, inaddition to all other advice, one instruction which he would give to his companions was not to kill women and children.
In the existence of these fundamental instructions, to think that the companions and among them, Zaid bin Harithah(ra), whowaslikethefamilyof theHolyProphet (sa), killed or had a lady killed in the manner described by Ibni Sa‘d, cannot be accepted at all. Undoubtedly, in this narration, although the deed of killing has not been attributed to Zaid (ra), rather, it has been attributed to another Muslim, but since this instance occurred under thecommandof Zaid(ra), eitherway, theultimateresponsibility would fall on him. Moreover, regarding Zaid (ra), to think that he allowed for something of this nature to occur under his watch, knowing full well the teaching of the Holy Prophet (sa) cannot be accepted in the slightest. Invariably, if a woman commits a crime, she will receive the punishment of that crime and the Shari‘ah of no religion, nor the law of any country, excludes a woman from the punishment of a crime. Moreover, occurrences of the punishment of women, rather, even execution for the punishment of murder are printed on a daily basis. However, killing awoman merelyonaccount of religious enmity and more so, to kill her in the manner described in this narration, is such an action as is clearly rejected by the fundamental instruction of the Holy Prophet (sa) and the whole of Islamic history. Furthermore, if it is stated that this lady was a criminal and as mentioned in variousnarrations, sheconspiredtoassassinatetheHoly Prophet (sa) and for this reason the sentence of murder could be lawfully issued against her, then this is correct. Butthequestionis: if thecompanionsof theHolyProphet (sa) did not kill severer and more vicious criminals than UmmiQirfah– andmaleenemiesatthat– inthismanner, then to think that an elderly lady was treated in this way underthe watch of awell-informedcompanionthe like of ZaidbinHarithah(ra), iscompletelyunacceptable. Hence, from arational perspective, the falsehoodandfabrication of thisstoryisevidentandclearandnoimpartialindividual could find room to doubt this.
Now remains the aspect of narration. Hence, firstly, Ibni Sa‘d or Ibni Ishaq have not provided authentication for this narration and without a reliable source, a narration of this kind which is contradictory to the clear instruction of the Holy Prophet (sa) and the common and well-known practice of the companions, cannot be acceptedatall. Secondly, thisveryaccounthasbeenmentioned in Sahih Muslim and Sunan Abi Dawud, which are two very authentic books of Hadith, but the mention of Ummi Qirfah being killed has not been mentioned at all. Furthermore, in various other details, this account differs to that of Ibni Sa‘d and others. Moreover, Sahih Ahadith are definitely and universally accepted as far more reliable and worthy of preference. For this reason, the narration of Ibni Sa‘d and others have no weight in comparison to that of Sahih Muslim and Sunan Abu Dawud. This distinction becomes further evident when webearinmindthatwhereIbniSa‘dandIbniIshaqhave mentionedtheirnarrationswithoutanyauthentication, on the other hand, Imam Muslim and Abu Dawud have furnished complete authentication for their narrations. Eitherway, incomparisontothe cautionpractised bythe Muhaddithin who worked very prudently, the general narrations of historians possess no value.
Themanner inwhichthisaccounthasbeenrecorded in Sahih Muslim and Sunan Abu Dawud has already been mentioned above. In it, there is not even mention of the killing of Ummi Qirfah. Invariably, in the narration of Muslim and Abu Dawud, the name of Ummi Qirfah isnotmentionedandthenameof thecommanderisalso recordedasAbu Bakr(ra) insteadof Zaid(ra). Regardless, we cannot imagine that this expedition was another one altogether, as the rest of the significant details are the same in their totality. For example:
It is described in both these narrations that this expedition was against the Banu Fazarah.
Itismentionedinboththesenarrationsthatthechieftain of the Banu Fazarah was an elderly lady.
Both narrations mention the imprisonment of this lady.
It is mentioned in both of these narrations that this lady had a
daughter, who was also imprisoned with her.
Both narrations mention that this girl was given to the lot of
Salmah bin Akwa‘ (ra).
Additionally, there are similarities in other facts as well. Now contemplate, in the presence of these significant and fundamental commonalities, is it possible for an individual to imagine that these were two different accounts? However, we do not rest on this rational argumentation alone, rather, researchers of the past have clearly written that the account of Sahih Muslim and Sunan Abi Dawud is the same one which Ibni Sa‘d has recordedinanothermanner. Assuch,‘AllamahZurqani, Imam Suhaili and ‘Allamah Halabi have clearly written that this is the same account which Ibni Sa‘d and Ibni Ishaqhaveerroneouslymentionedinthestoryof Ummi Qirfah. However, morethanthis, proof of thefactthatthis is the same account is that Tabari has mentioned both thesenarrationssidebysideandclearlywrittenthatboth these accounts are but one and the same thing.
Therefore, it is completely undeniable that in the narration of Salmah bin Akwa‘ (ra) recorded by Muslim and Abu Dawud, the very same account has been mentioned, which Ibni Sa‘d and Ibni Hisham have erroneously recorded by the name of ‘Sariyyah of Ummi Qirfah’. Moreover, the narration of the Sihah which has been mentioned with authentication, and is narrated by one who participated in the event, is in any case, worthy of precedence to the unauthenticated narration of Ibni Sa‘d and Ibni Hisham. For this reason, there is no room for doubt in the fact that the account of the ‘barbaric murder’ of Ummi Qirfah is a completely false account withoutfoundation, whichduetothe‘favour’of ahidden enemy of Islam or a hypocrite, has found its way into some historical narrations. The truth is that the verity of this Sariyyah is nothing more than what Muslim and Abu Dawud have mentioned. It is not surprising for an erroneousaccounttoberecordedinhistory, becausesuch examples are found in the history of every country and nation. It is surprising, however, for a man like Sir William to give this erroneous account a place in his book without any investigation and to openly confess that the purpose of his recording it was merely as an example of a cruel deed of the Muslims was found in it.’
(The Life and Character of the Seal of Prophets (sa), Vol. 3, pp. 74-79)
Expedition of Abdullah bin Atik (ra)
His Holiness (aba) said that then there was the Expedition of Abdullah bin Atik which was sent towards Abu Rafi’. His Holiness (aba) quoted Hazrat Mirza Bashir Ahamd (ra) who writes:
‘Thereisadisagreementamongstnarrationswithregardstothekillingof AbuRafi‘. Inthefollowingof Zuhri, Bukhari has simply mentioned it as having occurred after the killing of Ka‘b bin Ashraf, without specifying a date, which is true either way. Perhaps both these accounts havebeen mentioned together since theirnature is identical. Tabarihasputitin3A.H., aftertheoccurrenceof Ka‘b bin Ashraf. Waqidi hasmentionedit in 4A.H. Referringto Ibni Ishaq, Ibni Hisham has simply recorded it as being after the Ghazwah of Banu Quraizah, which took place towards the end of 5 A.H. and in this manner, it can be consideredashavingoccurredinthebeginningof 6A.H. However, Ibni Sa‘d has specifically recorded it in 6 A.H. and most historians have taken the stance of Ibni Sa‘d. Allah knows best.’
(The Life and Character of the Seal of Prophets (sa), Vol. 3, pp. 83-84)
How the Killing of Abu Rafi’ Unfolded
HisHoliness(aba) furtherquotedHazratMirzaBashir Ahmad (ra) who writes:
‘The mischief-making and instigation of the Jewish Chieftainsresultedinthedangerousconflictof theBattle of Ahzab against the Muslims in 5 A.H. Among them, Huyaiy bin Akhtab had already met his end along with the Banu Quraizah. However, Sallam bin Abil-Huqaiq, whoseappellationwasAbuRafi‘, wasstillengagedfreely inhismischief-makingasbefore, intheregionof Khaibar. Rather, the humiliating failure of Ahzab and the terrible endof theBanuQuraizahhadonlyfurtherincreasedhis animosity. Since the settlement of the tribes of Ghatafan weresituated near Khaibar and theJewsof Khaibar were asif neighbourstothetribesof Najd, forthisreason, Abu Rafi‘ who was a very affluent and influential merchant, had made it a custom to incite the barbaric and warmongering tribes of Najd against the Muslims. In his animosity towards the Holy Prophet (sa), he was the like of Ka‘b bin Ashraf. As such, during that era which we are mentioning now, he had given the Ghatafani people very significantfinancialaid inorder tolaunchanassault against the Holy Prophet (sa). Furthermore, it is proven by history that the Jews of Khaibar who were creating disorder in the watch of Abu Rafi‘, were also behind the threat which emerged against the Muslims by the Banu Sa‘d in the month of Sha‘ban for the defence of which an army was sent from Madinah under the leadership of Hazrat ‘Ali (ra).
However, Abu Rafi‘ did not suffice with this, and his enmity was thirsty for Muslim blood and the person of theHoly Prophet(sa) wasathorninhiseye. Therefore, ultimatelytheplanwhichheemployedwasthatinthelikeness of the Battle of Ahzab, he once again began to tour theGhatafantribesandothertribes, andbegantogather a grand army to destroy the Muslims. When the state of affairs reached this extent and the scenes of Ahzab once again began to appear before the eyes of the Muslims, a fewAnsar fromtheKhazrajpresentedthemselvesbefore the Holy Prophet (sa) and said, “Now, the solution to this turmoilisnothingbuttoputanendtothemastermindof this unrest.” Considering the fact that the elimination of a single mischief-maker and seditious person was more preferablethanmassbloodshedthroughouttheland, the Holy Prophet (sa) granted permission to these companions. Hesentfour companionsfromtheKhazraj under the leadershipof ‘Abdullahbin‘AtikAnsari(ra) towardsAbu Rafi‘. However, as he sent them he emphasised, “Look here, do not at all kill any woman or child.” Therefore, in the month of Ramadan 6 A.H. this party set off, and returned after very skillfully completing its mission. In thismanner, these cloudsof calamity dispersed from the skyof Madinah. Thedetailsof thisaccountasmentioned in Bukhari, which is the most authentic in this regard, have been recorded as such:
“Bara’ bin ‘Azib narrates that the Holy Prophet (sa) sent a party of his companions to kill Abu Rafi‘ the Jew, andappointed‘Abdullahbin‘Atikastheirleader. Thestory of Abu Rafi‘ is that he would inflict great grief on the Holy Prophet (sa) and would incite and help people against the Holy Prophet (sa). When ‘Abdullah bin ‘Atik and his companionsreachednearthecastleof AbuRafi‘ andthe sunhadset, ‘Abdullahbin‘Atiklefthiscompanionsbehind andproceededtothegateof thecastle. Hecoveredhimself with his mantle and sat down as if answering the call of nature. When the gate-keeper approached the entrance of the castle, he called out to ‘Abdullah bin ‘Atik and said, ‘O servant of Allah, enter if you wish, for I am about to close the gate.’ Still covered in his mantle, ‘Abdullah bin ‘Atik quickly entered the gate and hid to one side of the castle. The gate-keeper closed the gate, hung the key on a nearbypegandleft. Afterthis, thenarrationof ‘Abdullah bin ‘Atik himself begins. Hesays, ‘First and foremost, I got upandopenedthelockonthegate, sothataswiftandeasy exit was possible if needed. At the time, Abu Rafi‘ was in a room of his, and many people were seated around him in a night assembly talking to each other. When these people dispersed and it became silent I climbed the stairs to the home of Abu Rafi‘. I was careful that whenever I came to a door, I would enter it and close it from behind. WhenIreachedtheroomof AbuRafi‘, hehadputoutthe lantern and was preparing to fall asleep. The room was pitch dark. I called out the name of Abu Rafi‘ to which he responded, ‘Who is there?’ So I sprung towards the sourceof thevoiceand made asingle andpowerful strike of the sword. However, it was very dark, and due to my perplexity, Imissedhim. AbuRafi‘ criedout, uponwhich Ilefttheroom. Aftersometime, Ienteredtheroomagain, and changing my voice inquired, ‘O Abu Rafi‘ what is this noise?’ He could not recognise my changed voice and said, ‘May your mother forsake you, someone has just now attacked me with a sword.’ Upon hearing this voice, I sprung towards him again and struck him with the sword. This time, my strike was on point but he was stillnotdead, uponwhichIattackedhimathirdtimeand killed him. After this, I quickly opened the doors one by one till I reached outside of the home. However, when I was descending the stairs, there were still a few steps left, and I thought I had reached the ground due to which I fell down and broke my leg (and in another narration it is mentioned that the leg was dislocated). However, I tied it with my turban and dragged myself out, but I said to myself that until I am fully satisfied that Abu Rafi‘ is dead, I shall not leave. Therefore, I hid in a place near the castle. The next morning, I heard the voice of someone from inside the castle saying, ‘Abu Rafi‘, the merchant of Hijaz, has died. Thereupon, I got up, and slowly but gradually met with my companions. Upon arriving in Madinah, we informed the Holy Prophet (sa) of thedeath of Abu Rafi‘. Upon listening to the entire account, the Holy Prophet (sa) said, ‘Stretch out your broken leg.’ I stretched out my leg and the Holy Prophet (sa) rubbed his blessed hand upon it while praying, and I felt as if I had never had any ailment whatsoever.’”








