Sun, 22 Nov 2026

Celebrate Naija

telling the Nigerian story

Your Favourite Celebs

‘Sterling Point’ Is Comfort-Food YA Drama, Flaws and All

If you’re looking for a heartfelt, nostalgic teen drama peppered with romance and mystery, Prime has a show for you.

Created by Megan Park (My Old Ass) and produced by the team behind Gossip Girl, Sterling Point follows a rich girl whose life gets turned upside down when she inherits part of her family’s Canadian land. It has the feel of nostalgic teen classics like Dawson’s Creek and One Tree Hill, with an undercurrent of a modern mystery. 

In the first episode, we meet twin siblings, overachiever Annie (Ella Rubin) and disinterested Connor (Keen Ruffalo), who learn their estranged grandfather has died and left them property on an island in Canada. When their mother died, leaving behind their distant father (Jay Duplass), she also left behind questions Annie can now get help answering. Considering it doesn’t look like she’s going to get into her favorite school, Annie has nothing to lose.

If this feels like too much spoiler, this is the first ten minutes of Sterling Point. The opening is a whirlwind of thickly laid-on character development and exposition. It’s not subtle, and it’s not elegant, but the writing gets you quickly into the action. Sterling Point is refreshingly upfront in what it is and what it wants to do.

Sterling Point Opens Up A World Of Family Trauma

Sterling Point review
Amazon Prime Video

Once on Sterling Point, Annie discovers that her grandfather didn’t just leave them a cottage, he left them the whole island. And it’s not any island; it’s a Hamptons-style luxury getaway full of hard-working locals and snobby inhabitants. But when she gets to the cottage, she finds a woman called Ramona (Amélie Hoeferle) living there who claims that her grandfather owns it. 

This trip opens up a can of worms about Annie’s life and her late mother. She suddenly realizes that everything she knew about her family and legacy wasn’t quite as it seems. But the show is less concerned with following Annie’s trauma and more about exploring the messy personal lives of the inhabitants of the picturesque Canadian island. 

Annie very quickly fits in and finds friends, despite being a New York outsider. This isn’t a show that slowly moves toward the plot; it rushes through everything, but at least it’s not boring. We are quickly introduced to Ramona and her long-time friend/ love interest Oona (Bo Bragason), her more reasonable younger sibling Maple (Mabel Strachan), lothario Ellis (Jacob Whiteduck-Lavoie), and the fabulous Sully (Nikko Angelo Hinayo). And like any good teen drama, you also have two love interests for Annie: Rory (Daniel Quinn-Toye) and Ellis (Jacob Whiteduck-Lavoie), creating the perfect YA love triangle.

The biggest conflict on the island predominantly comes from the tensions between the rich tourists in their vacation properties and the working-class people who call it home all year round. This includes Ellis and his dad (Jeffrey Dean Morgan), who try to milk the tourists to maximize their own profits. Don’t expect too many political points, if any, about this. It’s just a way to ramp up some drama between the crushes and the kisses and the parties.

You are introduced so quickly to this world and these people that it can be hard to work out who is who and how they connect. It also takes a while to really care about their interpersonal relationships, as you’re left grasping who these people actually are. A standout here is Oona, a flirty, unapologetic type of girl who genuinely feels cool. Sully is also a warm light among this cast of apathetic teens.

Sterling Point: A Charming Way To Pass Your Time

You won’t find any Emmy-worthy performances here, but everyone is doing exactly what they need to do for a heartfelt YA drama. Ella Rubin is charming and handles the froth as well as the serious. Amélie Hoeferle and Bo Bragason (who has been cast in the upcoming The Legend of Zelda) are great, but mainly because their characters have a little more depth. The male characters have a little less to them, especially the love interests, and you will be forgiven for mixing them up.

The grown-up cast here are the glue of the series. Jefferey Dean Morgan has perfected this gruff working-class hero character, while Missi Pyle as an upmarket rich tourist is an absolute scene stealer. It is the younger cast and characters who people will fall in love with here.

Sterling Point doesn’t shy away from the YA drama tropes. In fact, it wears them as a badge of honor. You have dead parents, secret family member reveals, love triangles, queer romance, finding yourself away from home; you name it, it has it here. But, it’s presented in a 1990s nostalgic way rather than a badly written way. 

The show is at its best when it is investigating tougher themes like grief, loss, and the pain behind family secrets. Sometimes the tone feels uneven jumping between adult subjects and kitschy teen drama tropes. Like it’s unsure whether to commit to one or the other. Big dramatic reveals are often underplayed or sometimes totally cut away from. At times, it seems like the creators intended to make one type of deeper, family drama and then later edited it into a lighter, teen dramedy in post-production.

Sterling Point has a specific audience and will work for those looking for a lighter, YA drama to take their mind off real life. It’s not the best written or acted television of the year, but it’s full of charm, relatable characters, and predictable tropes. You’ll know in the first ten minutes what you are getting and if you want to buy what it’s selling. 

Rating: C

Follow us on MSN for more of the content like this.

Sterling Point

Sterling Point

Annie along with her twin brother were raised in New York by their single dad before they find out that their estranged grandfather left them an island on a lake in his will.

Release Date:
August 5, 2026

Director:

Megan Park

Cast:

Ella Rubin
,
Amélie Hoeferle
,
Jacob Whiteduck-Lavoie

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *